OTTAWA, Ont. — One body has been recovered and five crew members were still missing Thursday as recovery efforts continued following the crash of a Canadian Cyclone helicopter off the coast of Greece.
“All of them are heroes,” Prime Minister Justin Trudeau said when addressing the media Thursday.
In a news release Thursday afternoon, the Canadian Armed Forces said Sub-Lt. Abbigail Cowbrough, a maritime systems engineering officer originally from Toronto, was killed.
It also confirmed the names of the five missing crew members:
- Capt. Brenden Ian MacDonald, from New Glasgow, N.S.
- Capt. Kevin Hagen, from Nanaimo, B.C.
- Capt. Maxime Miron-Morin, from Trois-Rivieres, Que.
- Sub-Lt. Matthew Pyke, from Truro, N.S.
- Master Cpl. Matthew Cousins, from Guelph, Ont.
HMCS Fredericton and North Atlantic Treaty Organization allies continue to search for the other five members of the helicopter's crew, the release said.
The Royal Canadian Air Force CH-148 Cyclone helicopter from 12 Wing Shearwater was participating in NATO training exercises off the west coast of Greece on Wednesday evening.
Chief of Defence Staff Gen. Jonathan Vance said the Cyclone took off from HMCS Fredericton, which was working alongside an Italian ship and a Turkish ship conducting basic inter-ship training, at 4:35 p.m. local time. The helicopter had concluded flight operations and was returning to the ship, and at 6:52 p.m. local time the ship lost contact with the air crew.
"As announced, 1 CAF member is deceased & 5 missing following a helicopter crash in the Ionian Sea. On behalf of the entire CAF I send our deepest condolences to her family, friends & shipmates. May her memory be a source of comfort & inspiration to us all. We will remember." JV pic.twitter.com/liB5KFnBgE
— General Jonathan Vance (@CDS_Canada_CEMD) April 30, 2020
Vance said a few moments later, flares were spotted in the water. A search and rescue mission was immediately launched with “every available resource” and has been ongoing since.
Vance said the flares were automatically deployed. He could not provide any information on whether a mayday call was received.
At a briefing Thursday at the Navy dockyard in Halifax, Read Admiral Craig Baines, commander of Maritime Command Component, said the search team consisted of four ships - the Fredericton, two Italian ships and two Turkish ships - along with shipboard helicopters and fixed-wing patrol aircraft from Italy, the United States and Greece.
“This search will continue through the evening and into tomorrow night,” said Baines, who added that debris associated with the helicopter had been found. “Search conditions are good, but we are now searching a much larger area given the effects of wind and current.”
Baines said Canada’s NATO allies have been “absolutely steadfast in supporting Canada in searching for our missing crew members and we thank them deeply for what they're doing.”
From the official Twitter account of the Turkish Ministry of National Defence:
Kanada’ya ait FREDERICTON Fırkateyni’nin İyon Denizi’nde düşen helikopterini arama çalışmaları dün geceden bu yana sürüyor. NATO SNMG-2’de görevli TCG SALİHREİS Fırkateynimiz ve beraberindeki helikopterimiz, kazanın gerçekleştiği noktada arama kurtarma çalışmalarına devam ediyor. pic.twitter.com/xfg69aEnkE
— T.C. Millî Savunma Bakanlığı (@tcsavunma) April 30, 2020
The rear admiral, along with Col. James Hawthorne, commander of 12 Wing Shearwater where the Cyclones are based, who also attended the briefing, conveyed “deepest sympathies” to the families and loved ones of the six crew members.
“In my last six years out here on the coast and in my memory being in the Royal Canadian Navy for the last 32 years, this is certainly one of the most tragic events that I recall,” he said.
“It is an absolutely horrific event to have happened for our air detachment and our ship's company.”
Asked whether the crash raised worries about the dependability of the Cyclone, Hawthorne said “I have no safety concerns at the moment.”
Vance also offered condolences to the families, friends and crewmates of those lost.
A search operation is still underway in the Ionian Sea for the five missing
“There are no words to describe the pain that you feel right now, nor are there any words that can ease it,” he said. “This is a time of agony. … There’s nothing worse than sending your shipmates over the horizon and losing contact.”
Defence Minister Harjit Sajjan said the cause of the crash is unknown.
Vance said while nothing can be ruled out at this point, he’s quite certain the crash was not a function of contact or a shoot-down.
“Operation Reassurance is an assurance and deterrence mission, meaning the alliance has put in-ground and at-sea capabilities to tell Russia and any adversaries to not interfere with European security (or) North Atlantic security, and also to assure allies we are all in this together,” Vance said.
“At the time of the accident the standing maritime group was conducting training and not conducting surveillance or particular targeted operations on any vessel, adversarial or otherwise.”
The Canadian Armed Forces now has the task of trying to figure out what went wrong.
Wreckage has not yet been recovered, but Vance said the flight data and cockpit voice recorders broke away from the helicopter separately during the crash, and an automatic beacon allowed the ship’s crew to locate it the next morning. The recorders are both being transported to the National Research Council for analysis.
“There is about 3,000 metres of water in the Ionian sea, so the search continues, and until the search is done, we won't really know the disposition of any wreckage,” Vance said.
A CAF flight safety team, similar to what would be deployed by the Transportation Safety Board for a domestic incident, was set to depart Canada on Thursday to travel to Greece to investigate the circumstances of the crash, along with a support team to help with logistics.
Vance said the Cyclone fleet, both in Canada and overseas, is under an operational pause — not a grounding — until officials can rule out a fleetwide problem with the choppers.
But Vance said he has no concerns with or lack of confidence in the fleet’s safety or performance.
“It performs terrifically. It’s got 9,000 hours on the fleet,” he said. “This is an accident and until we know, we won't be able to make any judgments on the airworthiness of the helicopter.”
He cited one other incident, a hard landing aboard Halifax-based Asterix in the Pacific Ocean in February 2019, but said an “unusual gust of wind” was responsible.
Cowbrough, 23, was identified by her parents Thursday as the first victim of the crash. Vance said Thursday she was a marine systems engineering officer.
“I am broken and gutted. Today, I lost my oldest daughter Abbigail Cowbrough in the crash involving the Cyclone from HMCS Fredericton,” Shane Cowbrough wrote in a Facebook post.
Less than a week before her death, Cowbrough posted a video to Facebook of her playing Amazing Grace on the bagpipes aboard HMCS Fredericton in Souda Bay, Crete — a tribute to those grieving the recent mass shooting in Nova Scotia.
“You can travel the world and still never meet anyone like an East Coaster. Glad to have been taken in by them, for I’d have it no other way,” Cowbrough wrote.
“To everyone back home, thinking of you,” she wrote, accompanied by the hashtag #NSstrong.
Cowbrough volunteered with the Union Fire Club Pipes and Drums, and played the bagpipes at her church in Dartmouth.
Vance would not provide details on why Cowbrough, not a usual flight crew member, was on board the helicopter when it crashed, other than to say she was authorized to be there and any additional details will be released when confirmed.
HMCS Fredericton, a Halifax-class frigate, departed from Halifax on Jan. 20 with about 240 personnel on board to take part in a six-month deployment in the Mediterranean Sea, part of Operation Reassurance, a NATO exercise that has been ongoing since 2014.
The ship was set to return to Canada in July.
The CH-148 Cyclone is a militarized version of the Sikorsky S-92 helicopter, and replaced Canada’s fleet of Sea Kings in 2018.
There have been several notable crashes of the Sikorsky S-92, most notably Cougar Helicopters Flight 491, which crashed en route to oil platforms off Newfoundland in March 2009, killing 17 of the 18 people on board.
With files from John McPhee
