• Print
  • Send to a friend
  • Comment (8)
  •  

Attempted theft results in jail time for city woman

Nancy MacPhee
Published on September 20, 2012
Published on September 20, 2012
Nancy MacPhee  RSS Feed

SUMMERSIDE — A 26-year-old city woman, who tried to steal a flat screen TV from a Moncton department store while on probation, is going to jail for seven days.

Topics :
Sears , Summerside , Moncton

Heidi Marie Arsenault pleaded guilty in provincial court in Summerside Thursday to the theft, two probation breaches and one charge of failing to appear in court.

The incident took place on April 21, 2011.

Security at Sears in Moncton, N.B., called police to report that they had Arsenault in custody. Security watched the woman as she moved throughout the store. She had gone to the electronics department and left with a $500 flat screen TV in her cart.

Arsenault hadn’t paid for the television. When she attempted to leave the store a security feature on the shopping cart, which causes the wheels to lock so it can’t be taken from the store, prevented her from getting out the door.

She tried several times to push the cart out the door. When she was approached by security she asked the officer to keep an eye on the cart and the television while she went outside to her car to get her receipt.

The security officer replied by questioning why the receipt would be in her car if she had just purchased the item.

“Ok, I took it,” said Arsenault.

At the time the crime was committed, she was on two separate probation orders, stipulations of which were to keep the peace and be of good behaviour.

Arsenault was arrested and given a date to appear in court. She failed to show up.

Her previous record included a number of convictions for theft. She had been court and convicted of theft less than three weeks before committing the crime.  

Defence attorney Trish Cheverie said since the crime, Arsenault has made “significant progress”, is working full-time and dealing with her addiction.

Cheverie asked that, in spite of her previous theft convictions, Arsenault not be given jail time.

Judge Jeff Lantz disagreed.

“It is a fairly significant item,” Lantz said of the television Arsenault tried to steal. “She had two prior convictions on her record at the time and was on probation.”

She was permitted to serve her sentence intermittently. Once out of jail, Arsenault will be on probation for 12 months and must undergo assessment, counselling and treatment for any addictions issues.

She was also ordered to pay $200 in victim surcharges and to stay away from the victimized store.

 

nmacphee@journalpioneer.com

 

Comments

  • Username
    outraged
    - September 21, 2012 at 19:02:32

    THINK FIRST.. perhaps you should take your own advice. Sadly i knew her before she got on the junk and she was one of the greatest people i have ever met. Scary how fast things change though. 6 months later she was nothing but another theiving junkie. As for her 'standing up and admitting to her crimes'.. well she got caught red handed. Kinda hard to deny it then you're caught red handed The very fact that less than 3 weeks prior to getting caught in Moncton she was convicted of theft in Summerside speaks volumes. Can you say 'repeat offender'? Even after getting caught did she stand up and go to court? nope. she bailed. So no.. she DIDN'T 'stand up and admit' what she did ! Difficult past aside.. i know what you are referring to and it is still no excuse. He would be shocked and sickened to see how far she has fallen. It was still HER choice and HER actions that brought about this stupidity. I hope WHEN she gets caught again the judge will remember this. Cause she's still not clean. Personally it makes me sick that people can commit a crime, then play nice for a few months and lo and behold they are rehabilitated and get very little jail time. WHO CARES WHAT SHE'S LIKE NOW? She committed the crime didn't she?? Why should she be exempt from punishment just because she got a job? If someone commits a crime they should be punished for that crime. Should a drunk driver be let off simply because they show up at court sober?

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    TO THINK FIRST
    - September 21, 2012 at 17:22:58

    Amazing how you think people who obey the laws and are upset about no punishment for CONVICTED CRIMINALS are losers. Clearly says a lot about you.enough said

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    john
    - September 21, 2012 at 16:32:09

    How did she get to Moncton in the first place,and why in hell are we dealing with a crime she commited in a different province anyways!!!!!!

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    I agree
    - September 21, 2012 at 14:20:11

    THINK FIRST..... Grow up...we all make choices in our lives everyday...The first day she decided to make a choice to do drugs and steal was hers..she made it..not me..I am not perfect in anyway..that is for sure..but when I do make wrong choices it is up to me to fix it..not wait for the world top do it or keep doing it over and over. I also have a life and a family and some of them have also made mistakes although I love them with all my heart ..they have to fix the mistakes.. I think that people who think like you just give them the chance to do it again and again...if they want help they will ask..they have to want the help first....you know the old story ..you can lead a horse to water but you can not make it drink. How many chances are enough..nip it in the bud..come down hard the first time..not 10 times later. Maybe the first time would help..who knows. We know they have a life and a family and I hope with all my heart they will be ok..BUT..these little (please don't do it again) sentences clearly do not work!!!

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    I agree
    - September 21, 2012 at 11:59:08

    I agree with the two commnts above...This is a joke..how many times do you get convicted before your NOT making progress...I get out of my bed everyday to go to work to pay the salery of the Judge and the Defence Attorney here..and this one can be charged 3 times or more..steal do what ever she wants and get away with it..as always the justice system stinks... Throw her in jail for at least a year and make her stay there for the full year..if she needs help and counselling she can get it there..if she makes real progress by the end of that year let her out..if not give her six months...this may sound silly to some..but the 1 week in jail sure sounds silly to me. I work hard everyday for people like her to go to court and get nothing so I may as well pay for them to stay in jail and maybe get help.

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    outraged
    - September 20, 2012 at 18:43:39

    So long as the courts continue slapping the wrists of these junkies the more junkies will steal from hard working people and stores. Throw their ass in jail! Where's the protection for the rest of us decent law abiding people? But of course.. the only people that egt protected are junkies who steal and then get cheverie to cry in court about how it's never the addicts fault but he drugs. get real!

    Submit a comment

  • Username
    MERRY GO ROUND
    - September 20, 2012 at 18:14:28

    previous convictions, Convicted 3 weeks prior for theft and her lawyer says she is making SIGNIFICENT PROGRESS. In what Ways to commit theft. Breach of probation, failing to appear and still only gets 7 days to be served on weekends. And people wonder why crime is so high here. NO PUNISHMENT.

    Submit a comment

    • Username
      Think First
      - September 21, 2012 at 12:10:35

      I invite you to think first people. This "junkie" as you are so quick to comment about, has a life AND a family. If you had read the article previously, you will note that the crime being dealt with here was committed well over a year ago - they do not talk about progress that was made during that time frame; because as we all know, much can happen in a year. She has a job, as mentioned in this article - if she is still a "junkie", she wouldn't be very employable, now would she? It's hard to overcome a difficult past, but it seems to me here that this person is trying to do so..... and you a quick to bash her, and give up on her as a human. Give her some credit for standing up and admitting to the offence; she will do all of her time and then some to rid of this past. I hope she is able to recover and move on, all I can say is take it one day at a time and forget losers who spend their days bringing down others.

Submit a comment

Submit a comment (we keep all emails private)
Agreement

We ask that users remain courteous. You may not post insulting, discriminatory or inappropriate content, which may be removed at our discretion. We are not responsible for user content and opinions. Use of this site as well as content submission & ownership are governed by our Conditions of Use and Privacy Policy.

Member organizations should be non-profit in nature, and promote legal activities. Any organization found promoting illegal activities or commercial products or services will be deleted from the site.

I agree with these conditions.

Advertising

Newsletter

Please enter your email to receive our free newsletter

Subscribe to news alerts

Advertising