NDP leader taking CBC debate decision to Parliament

Teresa Wright
Send to a friend

Send this article to a friend.

James Rodd, leader of the New Democratic Party of P.E.I.

P.E.I. NDP Leader James Rodd says he is disappointed in the CBC’s decision to limit the televised leaders debate to include only the Liberal and Progressive Conservative parties, and he wants to make a federal and legal issue of it.

Rodd said he plans to go to his federal counterparts in Ottawa, where the NDP holds the position of official Opposition status, and ask them to raise the issue in the House of Commons.

“We want to have this questioned on the floor of Parliament to ensure that public broadcasters give the full and open debates that are required under the democratic system,” said Rodd.

“I was quite disappointed that decision was made … We’ve been on the political scene here since the ’60s and before that in the ’40s under the CCF, (Cooperative Commonwealth Federation). So we’ve had a long history of being involved in elections on P.E.I. and to make an arbitrary position just seems so unfair.”

He issued a news release which stated the party is also considering seeking legal advice on the matter.

Last Thursday, CBC officials informed Rodd, as well as Green Party Leader Sharon Labchuk and Island Party Leader Billy Cann, they were not welcome to participate in the debate, which was scheduled to air on the public broadcaster’s supper-hour show Compass on Sept. 21.

A national media relations spokesperson for the CBC told The Guardian Thursday it was an editorial decision based on a number of factors, including whether the party has a reasonable likelihood of forming government.

Rodd took exception to this reasoning, calling it disrespectful and biased against the NDP.

“CBC managers — whether in Charlottetown, Halifax or Toronto — do not have a magic ball that tells them the outcome of elections,” Rodd is quoted as saying in a news release.

“If they did, they would have known that the New Democratic Party was going to form the official opposition following the May 2 federal election. And that’s certainly not what they — or most other media observers — were saying at the start of that campaign.”

Rodd also applauded PC Leader Olive Crane’s refusal to take part in the debate due to her belief the decision is unfair.

Contacted on the debate issue last Friday, Premier Robert Ghiz said he was definitely not going to participate alone.

He joked that being the only debater would increase his chances of winning the debate.

The premier said he was disappointed to learn the other registered parties were being excluded and had not been notified of the move earlier.

“They were anticipating being included. They were included last election. I think if the CBC really wants to make a policy decision on this they should do it well in advance of the election so that the other parties aren’t caught off guard.”

The premier said he didn’t know what the CBC’s motives were in making its decision.

“It is a decision of the CBC. It’s not a government decision,” he added.

“I’ll respect their jurisdiction in this manner and, like pretty much every other debate, if I can fit it into my schedule I generally like to make that debate. It’s important for democracy.”

Crane said she is demanding that CBC reverse its decision.

“While I would relish the opportunity to solely debate the Liberal leader, all five parties are registered under the rules required by Elections P.E.I. and therefore they all have a right to participate in all public debates,” Crane said.

With files from Transcontinental Media

Organizations: CBC, New Democratic Party, House of Commons Commonwealth Federation Green Party Leader Sharon Labchuk and Island Party

Geographic location: Ottawa, Charlottetown, Halifax Toronto

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Thanks for voting!

Top of page



Recent comments

  • bob from cardigan
    September 13, 2011 - 12:06

    Funny how we call it democracy when we limit debates to the two "official" parties.

  • SG
    September 12, 2011 - 23:03

    Jean: According to this report all parties, Liberals, NDP and PC were agreeable to Ms. May being included in the Federal Televised Debate. By CBC News, cbc.ca, Updated: March 30, 2011 http://news.ca.msn.com/federal-election-2011/cbc-article.aspx?cp-documentid=28184036 The broadcast consortium that independently governs debates, made up of representatives from CBC, Radio-Canada, CTV, Global and TVA, has decided that May would not be invited to take part. May reacted angrily, and both Liberal Leader Michael Ignatieff and the NDP's Jack Layton said they didn't mind her participation. Conservative Party Leader Stephen Harper, appearing in Brampton, Ont., said the Tories were open to any number of formats, including one involving the Green Party. He specifically mentioned a one-on-one debate with Ignatieff. "I hope that [the consortium] will consider the views of all Canadians, and everyone should be treated fairly," he said, speaking in French. May scheduled a press conference for 1 p.m. PT in Vancouver, and CBC News has learned she has hired a lawyer to plead her case. May was initially denied a spot at the 2008 leaders debates as well, at about this point in the campaign, but in the face of threatened legal action and public opinion, May was allowed to take part.

  • Camille
    September 12, 2011 - 22:52

    Priceless. The federal NDP couldn't care less about having democratic debates, as they helped shut Elizabeth May out of the federal leaders' debates in the 2011 election. And the NDP in Ontario and Manitoba are perfectly happy to silence the Greens by shutting them out of leaders' debates in elections in those provinces this fall. So the idea that the federal NDP might raise this in the House of Commons and somehow help him take legal action to get into the debate is laughable. It would expose the NDP's extreme hypocrisy. Good luck with that one, James Rodd.

  • SG
    September 12, 2011 - 22:45

    Kudos to PEI NDP Leader James Rodd for taking this to the Federal Level in Ottawa. I feel all Parties who paid to Register should be included. If all parties are campaigning for the Election why wouldn't all be included in a televised Political Debate?

  • Jean
    September 12, 2011 - 14:16

    It would be rather hypocritical if the federal NDP raised the issue in the House when they didn't really show any concern for the Green Party being excluded in the TV debate in the spring. That said, kudos to Crane and thumbs down to CBC--once again. Using taxpayers dollars to thwart democracy.